Why Trump’s Plan for the Strait of Hormuz is Falling Apart

Why Trump’s Plan for the Strait of Hormuz is Falling Apart

The Middle East just shifted again, and not in the way the White House hoped. On Tuesday, March 24, 2026, Iran didn't just ignore Donald Trump’s latest diplomatic overture—it answered with a massive barrage of ballistic missiles aimed directly at the heart of Israel. As sirens wailed in Tel Aviv and emergency crews scrambled to pull survivors from the rubble of residential buildings, the reality on the ground made one thing clear. The "very good and productive" talks Trump touted just 24 hours ago might not have existed at all.

You’ve likely seen the headlines about Trump’s proposal to share control of the Strait of Hormuz with the Iranian leadership. It’s a classic Trump move: a high-stakes, unconventional deal designed to settle a global crisis with a handshake. But Tehran isn't buying it. In fact, they’re laughing.

The Missile Barrage and the Mockery

While Trump was telling reporters that the Strait would be "open very soon" under joint U.S.-Iranian supervision, Iran was busy fueling up. The Tuesday morning attack saw waves of missiles penetrating Israeli airspace, striking targets in Tel Aviv and central Israel. Fire and Rescue services are currently reporting civilian traps in damaged structures, a grim contrast to the optimistic tone coming out of Washington.

But the real sting came from the Iranian response to the "joint control" idea. Iran’s Parliament Speaker, Mohammad Baqer Qalibaf—who the U.S. side identified as a key interlocutor—shattered the narrative on X. He didn't just deny a deal; he called the reports "fake news" used to manipulate oil markets.

The mockery got even more personal. The Iranian embassy in South Africa posted an image on social media that perfectly captured the regime's disdain: a pink toy steering wheel for a child, placed on a car dashboard. The message was unmistakable. Tehran views Trump’s "joint control" offer as a patronizing fantasy, a plastic wheel given to a toddler while someone else actually drives the car.

Why the Joint Control Idea is a Non Starter

Trump’s vision for the Strait of Hormuz sounds simple on paper. The U.S. and Iran would essentially co-manage the world’s most critical oil chokepoint, ensuring the flow of 15 million barrels of crude oil a day. But this ignores the brutal reality of the 2026 Iran War.

Since the U.S. and Israel launched "Operation Epic Fury" on February 28, the Iranian leadership has been decimated. The strikes reportedly killed Supreme Leader Ali Khamenei and several top officials. When Trump talks about "the Ayatollah, whoever the next Ayatollah is," he’s speaking to a vacuum. The current Iranian power structure is fractured, angry, and survival-focused. They aren't looking for a partnership; they're looking for revenge.

The Economic Mirage

One reason Trump might be pushing this narrative is the price of oil. The conflict pushed crude well over $100 a barrel, threatening the global economy and his domestic standing. When he announced the five-day delay on striking Iranian power plants to allow for "negotiations," the markets reacted instantly. Prices dipped. Stock futures rose.

But those gains are evaporating. You can’t stabilize a market with "productive talks" that one side claims never happened. The Strait remains a graveyard for shipping. Since the start of March, at least 18 vessels have been attacked. The U.S. Navy claims the Iranian navy is functionally destroyed, yet the threat persists. As we saw with the Houthi rebels in 2024, you don't need a massive fleet to shut down a strait; you just need enough shore-based missiles to make insurance companies stay home.

The Reality of Regime Change

Trump has been surprisingly blunt about the situation. He openly admitted that "there’s automatically a regime change" because of the initial strikes that wiped out senior leaders. Yet, in the same breath, he claims to be dealing with "very reasonable" people within the Iranian system.

This is the central contradiction. You can't dismantle a government and then expect the survivors to sit down for a cooperative maritime agreement. The "reasonable" people Trump is talking about are likely desperate factions trying to avoid further bombardment, but they don't seem to have the authority to stop the IRGC from launching missiles at Tel Aviv.

The Human and Military Cost so Far

  • Israel: Over 20 civilians killed and thousands injured since the escalation began.
  • Iran: Over 6,000 military personnel killed and its nuclear infrastructure at Natanz and Bushehr heavily damaged.
  • U.S.: Significant damage to bases across the region, including sites in Bahrain and Jordan.

What Happens Next

If you’re waiting for the "joint control" of the Strait to begin, don't hold your breath. The five-day pause Trump promised on striking Iranian energy infrastructure is ticking away. If the missiles keep flying into Israel, that pause will end with a massive escalation.

Iran has already promised to hammer the infrastructure of U.S. allies in the region if their power plants are hit. We aren't moving toward a shared steering wheel; we're moving toward a total blackout.

Keep a close eye on the oil markets over the next 48 hours. If the Iranian denials hold and the missile strikes continue, that dip below $100 was just a blip. The Strait of Hormuz isn't opening "very soon." It’s becoming the front line of a much larger, much uglier war.

If you're looking for a way to hedge against the coming volatility, look at energy sectors outside the Gulf. The era of "joint control" died before it even started, buried under the rubble in Tel Aviv.

BA

Brooklyn Adams

With a background in both technology and communication, Brooklyn Adams excels at explaining complex digital trends to everyday readers.